Suggestions by @amyhoward

Clark Gregg

as Paul Kelly in Heathers: The Musical (Animated)

Score: +1

Casey Cott

as Ram Sweeney in Heathers: The Musical (Animated)

Score: +1

Shannon Purser

as Martha Dunstock in Heathers: The Musical (Animated)

Score: +1

Matthew Morrison

as Director in Heathers the musical

Score: +1

Jayma Mays

as Pauline fleming in Heathers the musical

Score: +1

Grant Gustin

as J.D in Heathers The Musical

Score: +1

Ashley Fink

as Martha Dunnstock in Heathers The Musical

Score: +4

Alexis Bledel

as Veronica Sawyer in Martin Scorsese's Heathers

Score: -3

Milo Ventimiglia

as Jason "J.D." Dean in Martin Scorsese's Heathers

Score: -2

Rose McGowan

as Heather Duke in Martin Scorsese's Heathers

Score: -3

Matthew Morrison

as Veronica's Dad in Martin Scorsese's Heathers

Score: +1

Jenna Ushkowitz

as Thea Mack in Lights Out

Score: +2

Patrick Stewart

as Mr. Wakely in Silent Night

Score: +1

Max Adler

as Robb Spring in Silent Night

Score: +1

Madelaine Petsch

as Rachel West in The Prom Queen

Score: 0

Hart Denton

as Doug Fredericks in First Date

Score: +1

Mateus Ward

as Tim Sparks in First Date

Score: +1

Kelli Berglund

as Chelsea Richards in First Date

Score: +1

Peyton List

as Nina Darwin in First Date

Score: +1

Ross Lynch

as Paul Gordon in The New Boy

Score: +1