Suggestions by @amyd723

Bryan tyree henry

as Muddy Waters in Cadillac Records. (Broadway)

Score: +1

Lilli Cooper

as Etta James in Cadillac Records. (Broadway)

Score: +1

Okieriete Onaodowan

as Howlin' Wolf in Cadillac Records. (Broadway)

Score: +1

Guy Nardulli

as Johnny Camareri in Moonstruck

Score: +1

Guy Nardulli

as Johnny Cammareri in Moonstruck

Score: +1

Adam Lambert

as Judas Iscariot in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Olga Merediz

as Dolores Reyna in Zoot Suit

Score: +1

Carlos Gómez

as Enrique Reyna in Zoot Suit

Score: +1

Kiril Kulish

as Dog Boy in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)

Score: +1

Jeremy Jordan

as PT Barnum in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)

Score: +6

Phillipa Soo

as Understudy for Jenny Lind in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)

Score: +1

Phillipa Soo

as Charity Hallett Barnum in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)

Score: +2

Jeremy Jordan

as PT Barnum in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)

Score: +2

Jonathan Bailey

as Phillip Carlyle in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)

Score: +2

Jonathan Bailey

as Phillip Carlyle in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)

Score: +1

Alexandra Silber

as Lucille Frank in Parade

Score: +1

Angelique Rivera

as Della Barrios in Zoot Suit

Score: +1

Yadira Guevara-Prip

as Cookie in The Capeman

Score: +1

Paulina Chávez

as Gata in Mi Vida Loca

Score: +1

Denyse Tontz

as Understudy for Rosie in La Bamba (On Broadway)

Score: +1