Suggestions by @amblinone

Timothy Dalton

as Alfred Pennyworth in All New Justice League

Score: -4

Ray Liotta

as Carmine Falcone in Batman Reboot by Matt Reeves

Score: 0

Paul Dano

as Jonathan Crane in Batman Reboot by Matt Reeves

Score: -2

Bo Burnham

as Edward Nygma in Batman Reboot by Matt Reeves

Score: 0

Saoirse Ronan

as Selina Kyle in Batman Reboot by Matt Reeves

Score: -3

Stephen Graham

as The Penguin in Matt Reeve's 'The Batman' + Future Film Speculation Casting

Score: 0