Suggestions by @alydank
34 suggestions
Tom Bateman
as The Freak in Still Missing
Alexandra Daddario
as Annie in Still Missing
Christie Brinkley
as Lorraine in Still Missing
Victoria Pedretti
as Persephone Fraser in Every Summer After
Timothy Olyphant
as Walt Jenkins in Twenty Years Later
Lucy Hale
as Mallory Quinn in Hidden Pictures
Barbie Ferreira
as Roxy in None of this is true
Octavia Spencer
as Mrs. Green in The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
Tom Bateman
as Carter Campbell in The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
January Jones
as Patricia Campbell in The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
Scott MacArthur
as Mark in How To Sell A Haunted House
Meghann Fahy
as Sabrina in Happy Place
Vanessa Morgan
as Cleo in Happy Place
Oliver Jackson-Cohen
as Mark in How To Sell A Haunted House
Sam Chaflin
as Jamie Kelley in The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches
Richa Moorjani
as Mika Moon in The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches
Alexandra Daddario
as Mindy in The Last Time I Lied
Natalia Dyer
as Emma in The Last Time I Lied
Alexander Skarsgård
as Adam in Behind closed doors
Penn Badgley
as Adam in The Perfect Marriage