Suggestions by @aluminumforest

Elizabeth Banks

as Princess Peach in Super Mario Sunshine (NCU)

Score: +1

Paul Rudd

as Luigi in Super Mario Sunshine (NCU)

Score: +1

Jack Black

as Mario in Super Mario Sunshine (NCU)

Score: +1

Juno Temple

as Post-Credits Scene Cameo in Super Mario Sunshine (NCU)

Score: +1

Spoiler

as Post-Credits Scene Cameo in Super Mario Sunshine (NCU)

Score: +1

Juno Temple

as Post-Credits Scene Cameo in Super Mario Sunshine (NCU)

Score: +1

Jai Courtney

as Scourge The Hedgehog in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Mark Strong

as Dr. Eggman in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Ross Marquand

as Metal Sonic in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Tara Strong

as Cream The Rabbit in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Elisabeth Moss

as Amy Rose in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Viggo Mortensen

as Knuckles The Echidna in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Miles “Tails” Prower in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Roger Craig Smith

as Sonic The Hedgehog in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Post-Credits Scene Cameo in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Spoiler

as Post-Credits Scene Cameo in Sonic The Hedgehog (NCU)

Score: +1

Linda Cardellini

as Wendy O. Koopa in Super Mario Bros. (NCU)

Score: +1

Jason Marsden

as Iggy Koopa in Super Mario Bros. (NCU)

Score: +1

Tony Hale

as Lemmy Koopa in Super Mario Bros. (NCU)

Score: +1

Jack Quaid

as Larry Koopa in Super Mario Bros. (NCU)

Score: +1