Suggestions by @alritestoodeos

Roger Dale Floyd

as Benjamin Lawman in Slendermansion

Score: +1

Ariana Greenblatt

as Sally Maryam Williams in Slendermansion

Score: +1

Jack Champion

as Brian Thomas in Slendermansion

Score: +1

Sophie Mousel

as Natalie Oullette in Slendermansion

Score: +1

Hailee Steinfeld

as Jane Arkensaw in Slendermansion

Score: -1

Emma Myers

as Jane Arkensaw in Slendermansion

Score: -1

Steve Buscemi

as Nebbercracker in Monster House Live Action Remake

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Laughing Jack in Slendermansion

Score: 0

Jacob Bertrand

as Jeffery Woods in Slendermansion

Score: +2

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Jack Nichols in Slendermansion

Score: +1

Tanner Buchanan

as BEN Drowned in Slendermansion

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as Slenderman in Slendermansion

Score: +1

Channing Tatum

as The Boss (President) in Saints Row IV Movie Fan Cast

Score: +3

Patton Oswalt

as CID in Saints Row IV Movie Fan Cast

Score: +1

Mark Strong

as Zinyak in Saints Row IV Movie Fan Cast

Score: +1

Frank Ocean

as Pierce Washington in Saints Row IV Movie Fan Cast

Score: +1

Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum

as Clockwork in Creepypastas Characters.

Score: -1

Dylan Wang

as Bloody Painter in Creepypastas Characters.

Score: +4

Sadie Sandler

as Nina The Killer in Creepypastas Characters.

Score: 0

Ariana Greenblatt

as Sally Williams in Creepypastas Characters.

Score: -2