Suggestions by @allnewalldifferent

John Logan

as Writer in Popeye

Score: +2

Gore Verbinski

as Writer in Popeye

Score: +1

Kathy Bates

as Sea Hag in Popeye

Score: +1

Khary Payton

as Poseidon in Popeye

Score: +1

David Tennant

as Dracula in Popeye

Score: +1

Richard Ridings

as Captain Eliot in Popeye

Score: +1

Tara Strong

as Charlotte de Berry in Popeye

Score: +1

Ram Charan

as Captain Nemo in Popeye

Score: +1

Gary Chalk

as Bluto in Popeye

Score: +1

Tabitha St. Germain

as Olive Oyl/Swee'Pea in Popeye

Score: 0

Billy West

as Popeye The Sailor/Poopdeck Pappy in Popeye

Score: +1

Keith David

as Sinbad The Sailor in Popeye

Score: +1

Chris Diamantopoulos

as Steamboat Willie in Popeye

Score: +1

Matt Hill

as J. Wellington Wimpy in Popeye

Score: +1

Andrew Lincoln

as Silver Surfer in Cosmic Compass

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as Galactus in Cosmic Compass

Score: +1

Kola Bokinni

as Desak in Cosmic Compass

Score: +1

Tony Todd

as Mephisto in Cosmic Compass

Score: +1

Charlie Clapham

as Doctor Doom in Cosmic Compass

Score: +1

Benedict Wong

as Wong in Cosmic Compass

Score: +1