Suggestions by @aliendutch5

Childish Gambino

as Flyborg in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Next Chapter

Score: +2

Edward Norton

as Hulk in New MCU

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as Iron Man in New MCU

Score: +2

Winslow Fegley

as Human Spider in New MCU

Score: +1

River Phoenix

as Mike Wheeler in Stranger Things (1980s)

Score: +1

Zac Efron

as Wolverine in X-Men Reboot

Score: 0

Tony Revolori

as Cyclops in X-Men Reboot

Score: -3

Winslow Fegley

as Bruce Wayne in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: 0

Jack Black

as Lonnie Byers in Montauk

Score: +1

Naomi Watts

as Joyce Byers in Montauk

Score: +1

Violet McGraw

as Eleven in Montauk

Score: +1

Hero Hunter

as Lucas Conley in Montauk

Score: +1

Archie Yates

as Dustin Henderson in Montauk

Score: +1

Zoe Colletti

as Barb in Montauk

Score: +1

Oakes Fegley

as Jonathan Byers in Montauk

Score: +1

Azhy Robertson

as Benny Byers in Montauk

Score: +1

Ewan McGregor

as Jim Hopper in Montauk

Score: +1

Charles Halford

as Terry Ives in Montauk

Score: +1

Peter Coyote

as Agent One in Montauk

Score: +1