Suggestions by @aliendutch5

Eric Woolfe

as Elf 7 in Violent Night 2: Violenter Night

Score: +1

John Leguizamo

as Scrooge in Violent Night 2: Violenter Night

Score: +1

Lily Allen

as Mrs. Claus in Violent Night 2: Violenter Night

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Santa Claus in Violent Night 2: Violenter Night

Score: +1

Ben Platt

as Seymour Krelborn in Little Shop of Horrors

Score: +2

Danny Mefford

as Choreographer in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Benj Pasek

as Composer in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Steven Levenson

as Writer in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Justin Paul

as Producer in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Michael Greif

as Director in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Kristolyn Lloyd

as Alana Beck in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Jennifer Laura Thompson

as Cynthia Murphy in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Laura Dreyfuss

as Zoe Murphy in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Mike Faist

as Connor Murphy in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Will Roland

as Jared Kleinman in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Rachel Bay Jones

as Heidi Hansen in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Michael Park

as Larry Murphy in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Ben Platt

as Evan Hansen in Dear Connor Murphy

Score: +1

Ego Nwodim

as April O'Neil in Colin Jost's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Next Chapter

Score: 0

Hero Hunter

as Leonardo in Colin Jost's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Next Chapter

Score: 0