Suggestions by @alfredvanhiggenshmuter

Timothy Spall

as Penguin in DC Universe Reboot - Fan Casting

+7-6Score: +1

Rainn Wilson

as Harvey Bullock in DC Universe Reboot - Fan Casting

+4-4Score: 0

Bryan Cranston

as Commissioner Gordon in DC Universe Reboot - Fan Casting

+13-2Score: +11

Zachary Quinto

as Scarecrow in DC Universe Reboot - Fan Casting

+3-3Score: 0

Bill Nighy

as Alfred Pennyworth in DC Universe Reboot - Fan Casting

+14-7Score: +7