Suggestions by @alexanderburke

Richard Armitage

as James ‘Logan’ Howlett in MCU X-Men

Score: -7

Logan Marshall-Green

as X-O Manowar in Valiant Comics fancast

Score: -5

Joe Manganiello

as Deathstroke in Robert Pattinson Batman Rogues Gallery

Score: +1

Josh Gad

as The Penguin in Robert Pattinson Batman Rogues Gallery

Score: 0

Vanessa Hudgens

as Catwoman in Robert Pattinson Batman Rogues Gallery

Score: -7

Adam Beach

as Nightwolf in Mortal Kombat

Score: +1

Scott Adkins

as Baraka in Mortal Kombat

Score: -2

Doug Jones

as Reptile in Mortal Kombat

Score: +1

Jessica Henwick

as Mileena in Mortal Kombat

Score: +2

Ruby Rose

as Skarlet in Mortal Kombat

Score: +6

Daniel Wu

as Noob Saibot in Mortal Kombat

Score: 0

Dave Bautista

as Kotal Kahn in Mortal Kombat

Score: +3

Willem Dafoe

as Shinnok in Mortal Kombat

Score: +1

Boyd Holbrook

as Erron Black in Mortal Kombat

Score: +1

Ludi Lin

as Kung Lao in Mortal Kombat

Score: 0

Charles Dance

as Quan Chi in Mortal Kombat

Score: +1

Paula Patton

as Jade in Mortal Kombat

Score: -2

Jessica Henwick

as Kitana in Mortal Kombat

Score: +2

Cary-Hiroyuki Tagawa

as Shang Tsung in Mortal Kombat

Score: +7

Mackenzie Davis

as Sonya in Mortal Kombat

Score: +1