Suggestions by @aleighh

Rachael Harris

as Linda in Hooked

Score: +1

William Zabka

as Police Commissioner Reginald in Hooked

Score: +1

Max Carver

as Twin #2 in Hooked

Score: +1

Charlie Carver

as Twin #1 in Hooked

Score: +1

Tyler Hoechlin

as Arthur Barrie in Hooked

Score: +1

Colin O'Brien

as Young James in Hooked

Score: +1

Emma Kenney

as Maria in Hooked

Score: +1

Riele Downs

as Angie in Hooked

Score: +1

Denny Love

as Curly in Hooked

Score: +1

Madison Rojas

as Jonathan Michaels in Hooked

Score: +1

Maika Monroe

as Tina Belle in Hooked

Score: +1

Austin Abrams

as Smee in Hooked

Score: +1

Leo Howard

as Starkey in Hooked

Score: +1

Bianca Santos

as Moira in Hooked

Score: +2

Nick Frost

as Roofus in Hooked

Score: +1

Benjamin McKenzie

as Peter Michaels in Hooked

Score: +2

Katie Douglas

as Wendy Michaels in Hooked

Score: +1

Troian Bellisario

as Aly Cappellucci in Lights Out

Score: -1

Larry Miller

as Headmaster Dixon in Hooked

Score: +1

Celeste O'Connor

as Catalina in Nocticadia

Score: +1