Suggestions by @agustincardozo

Stevie Nicks

as Lilywhite Lilith in The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway

Score: +1

Peter Gabriel

as Rael in The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway

Score: +1

Macaulay Culkin

as Peter Cetera in Rockstars Biopics

Score: +1

Rachel Hurd-Wood

as Kate Bush in Rockstars Biopics

Score: 0

Zachary Gordon

as Bono Vox in Rockstars Biopics

Score: -1

Heather Graham

as Celine in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

Regina King

as Tara in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

Blake Clark

as Herman in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

Tracey Ullman

as Jean in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

Chris Rock

as Official Dan in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

Steve Buscemi

as Chick in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

David Spade

as Coop in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

Kevin James

as Kenneth in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

Rosemary Harris

as Mrs. Connelly in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

Linda Cardellini

as Nancy Kendricks in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +2

Adam Sandler

as Alex Rose in Duplex (Happy Madison Productions)

Score: +1

Linda Cardellini

as Mel Jones/Beldam in Coraline(Live Action)

Score: +5