Suggestions by @adrianpintado

Jim Malone (The Untouchables)

as Liam Cunningham in What if this actor played

Théoden

as Liam Cunningham in What if this actor played

E.J. Smith

as Liam Cunningham in What if this actor played

Henry Jones Sr

as Liam Cunningham in What if this actor played

Jack Driscoll

as Harrison Ford in What if this actor played

Jack Driscoll

as Kevin Costner in What if this actor played

Walter Donovan (Indiana Jones)

as Ralph Fiennes in What if this actor played

Marcus Brody

as Kenneth Branagh in What if this actor played

Carl Denham

as Robert De Niro in What if this actor played

Carl Denham

as Gene Hackman in What if this actor played

Thomas Byles

as Denholm Elliot in What if this actor played

Bilbo Baggins

as Denholm Elliot in What if this actor played

Josiah Trelawny

as Robin Williams in What if this actor played

Spicer Lovejoy

as Donald Sutherland in What if this actor played

Frodo Baggins

as Mark Hamill in What if this actor played

Uncle (Red Dead Redemption)

as Mark Hamill in What if this actor played

Reverend Swanson

as Johnny Depp in What if this actor played

Eddie Valentine

as Tom Hardy in What if this actor played

Neville Sinclair

as Jason Isaacs in What if this actor played

Neville Sinclair

as Pierce Brosnan in What if this actor played