Suggestions by @adddelle

Mike Colter

as Randall Shoop in Sim City 3000

Score: +1

Paul Giamatti

as Moe Biehl in Sim City 3000

Score: +1

Stephanie Hsu

as Constance Lee in Sim City 3000

Score: +1

Dexter Sol Ansell

as Bobby Barrows in Clock Tower: The First Fear

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as Simon Barrows in Clock Tower: The First Fear

Score: +2

Samara Weaving

as Mary Barrows in Clock Tower: The First Fear

Score: +2

Jacey Sink

as Lotte in Clock Tower: The First Fear

Score: +1

Zara Elaheh

as Anne in Clock Tower: The First Fear

Score: +1

Mia Talerico

as Laura Harrington in Clock Tower: The First Fear

Score: +1

Violet McGraw

as Jennifer Simpson in Clock Tower: The First Fear

Score: +2