Suggestions by @adammiller

Daniel Radcliffe

as Wolverine in X-Men Reboot

Score: -5

Zac Efron

as Wolverine in X-Men Reboot

Score: -12

Tessa Thompson

as Tess Vreeland in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Ming-Na Wen

as Judi Chang in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

J.K. Simmons

as Jacob Dread in Foolish Mortals

Score: +2

Matt Smith

as Harrison Hightower in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Mark-Paul Gosselaar

as George Hightower Jr in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Lynda Carter

as Cecile B Hightower in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Gal Gadot

as Cecile Hightower in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Jonathan Frakes

as George Hightower in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Kristen Schaal

as Millie Toomes in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Jesse L. Martin

as Silas Crump O'Dell in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Nathalie Emmanuel

as Grace Audley in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

William Jackson Harper

as Dominic Audley in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Patton Oswalt

as Gus in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Ezra in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Bill Hader

as Phineas in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as The Ghost Host in Foolish Mortals

Score: 0

Alison Brie

as Beating Heart Bride in Foolish Mortals

Score: 0

Jack Davenport

as Walter Gracey in Foolish Mortals

Score: +1