Suggestions by @adambaldwin1998

Zachary Levi

as Duke in Barnyard

Score: +3

Idris Elba

as Miles in Barnyard

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Ben in Barnyard

Score: 0

Michael Shannon

as Dag in Barnyard

Score: -1

Bill Hader

as Peck in Barnyard

Score: +2

Jim Parsons

as Freddy in Barnyard

Score: +1

Jim Gaffigan

as Pig in Barnyard

Score: 0

Keegan-Michael Key

as Pip in Barnyard

Score: -2

Emily Blunt

as Daisy in Barnyard

Score: +3

Jack Black

as Otis in Barnyard

Score: +2

Kevin Spacey

as Lord Hater in Wander Over Yonder

Score: +3

Goran Višnjić

as Lord Hater in Wander Over Yonder

Score: +2

Nathan Fillion

as Lord Hater in Wander Over Yonder

Score: +1

Chiwetel Ejiofor

as Lord Hater in Wander Over Yonder

Score: +2

Christoph Waltz

as Lord Hater in Wander Over Yonder

Score: +4

Peter Dinklage

as Lord Hater in Wander Over Yonder

Score: +4

Robert De Niro

as Lord Hater in Wander Over Yonder

Score: +1

Selena Gomez

as Sylvia in Wander Over Yonder

Score: -1

Sophia Bush

as Sylvia in Wander Over Yonder

Score: -1

Elizabeth Banks

as Sylvia in Wander Over Yonder

Score: +3