Suggestions by @acthepantherno1

Big Van Vader

as Fezzik in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +3

Robert Swenson

as Fezzik in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +3

Garry Robbins

as Fezzik in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +4

Nathan Lane

as Miracle Max in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +5

Joe Pantoliano

as Vizzini in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +5

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Count Tyrone Rugen in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +6

Pierce Brosnan

as Prince Humperdinck in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +4

Bill Nighy

as The Impressive Clergyman in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +4

Hugh Laurie

as The Albino in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +2

Bonnie Hunt

as Valerie in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +6

Elizabeth Perkins

as The Mother in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +2

Amy Yasbeck

as The Mother in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +3

Embeth Davidtz

as The Mother in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +3

Donald Sutherland

as The Grandfather in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +3

Anthony Hopkins

as The Grandfather in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +5

Kevin Nash

as Fezzik in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +3

20th Century Fox

as Distribution Company in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +2

Mark Knopfler

as Composer in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +2

William Goldman

as Writer in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +2

Rob Reiner

as Producer in The Princess Bride (1997)

Score: +2