Suggestions by @abba_mammamia

Luke Evans

as Freddie Trumper in Chess the Musical (film version)

Score: +2

Jessica Keenan Wynn

as Young Tanya Chesham-Leigh in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +3

Alexa Davies

as Young Rosie Mulligan in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +1

Lily James

as Young Donna Sheridan in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +2

Joanna Krupa

as Agnetha Fältskog in ABBA Biopic

Score: -1

Gael García Bernal

as Young Raphael Cienfuegos in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +2

Audrey Grace Marshall

as Child Donna Sheridan in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +5

Abbey Lee Kershaw

as Agnetha Fältskog in ABBA Biopic

Score: -1

Jason Dolley

as Björn Ulvaeus in ABBA Biopic

Score: +1

Wyatt Russell

as Benny Andersson in ABBA Biopic

Score: +1

Imogen Poots

as Agnetha Fältskog in ABBA Biopic

Score: 0

Miley Cyrus

as Young Ruby Sheridan in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +3

Jonathan Goldsmith

as Raphael Cienfuegos in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +1

Meryl Streep

as Donna Sheridan in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +1

Evan Rachel Wood

as Svetlana Sergievsky in Chess the Musical (film version)

Score: +2

Michelle Williams

as Svetlana Sergievsky in Chess the Musical (film version)

Score: -1

Anne Hathaway

as Florence Vassy in Chess the Musical (film version)

Score: +1

Summer Fontana

as Samantha Carmichael in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +3

Andy Garcia

as Fernando Cienfuegos in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +1

Christine Baranski

as Tanya Chesham-Leigh in Mamma Mia! 3

Score: +1