Suggestions by @a_colt_dagger_b

Brian Blessed

as Alaska in Face Claims Sorted by U.S. States

Score: +1

Larry the Cable Guy

as Pennsylvania in Face Claims Sorted by U.S. States

Score: -1

Tim Curry

as The Crypt Keeper in Tales from the Crypt (2020)

Score: +3

James Franco

as Commissioner James Gordon in Matt Reeve's 'The Batman' + Future Film Speculation Casting

Score: -1

John Goodman

as Harvey Bullock in Matt Reeve's 'The Batman' + Future Film Speculation Casting

Score: +1

Rowan Atkinson

as Alfred Pennyworth in Matt Reeve's 'The Batman' + Future Film Speculation Casting

Score: +2