Suggestions by @625rip

Neve Campbell

as Holy Sh*t! in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Spoiler

as Holy Sh*t! in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Ben Affleck

as Lieutenant Aaron Myers in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +3

Gemma Chan

as Hisami Dickinson in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Frances Conroy

as Sister Mary Helena in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +3

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Freddy Krueger in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Lennie James

as James Daniels in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +3

Jeremy Strong

as Dr. Joseph Haywood in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Heather Langenkamp

as Dra. Laura Brake in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +3

Kiernan Shipka

as Angela in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Jeremy Ray Taylor

as Philip in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Spike Fearn

as David in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +3

Amybeth McNulty

as Sasha in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Cristin Milioti

as Dra. Florence Schwartz in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +3

Asher Angel

as William Wright in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +3

Emma Myers

as Chloe Briggs in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +3

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Kevin Thompson in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Thomasin McKenzie

as Louise Dickinson in A Last Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Cristin Milioti

as Bride of Frankenstein in Bride of Frankenstein (2032)

Score: +13

Steven Caple Jr.

as Director in Avengers: The Theater of the Machines

Score: +2