Suggestions by @186fleetstreet

Daryl Sabara

as Ned Nickerson in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem

Score: +3

Aidan Quinn

as Carson Drew in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem

Score: +4

AnnaSophia Robb

as Nancy Drew in Nancy Drew: Midnight in Salem

Score: +3

Natalie Portman

as The Wicked Witch of the West in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3

Evangeline Lilly

as Nimee Amee in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3

Margo Harshman

as Miss Cayke in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +4

Daryl Sabara

as The Sawhorse in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3

Lou Diamond Phillips

as Nick Chopper in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +6

Vince Vaughn

as Shaggy the Mechanic in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3

Dominic Monaghan

as The Frogman in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3

Olivia Williams

as Glinda of the South in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3

Tahmoh Penikett

as Ugu in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3

Joel Grey

as The Wizard of Oz in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +2

Gary Oldman

as Kiki Aru in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3

Raviv Ullman

as Magic Rope in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Woot's Cafe Girl in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +6

Sara Paxton

as Mombi in Emerald City Confidential

Score: -2

Gwendoline Christie

as Mombi in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +4

Eddie Izzard

as Woot in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +5

Mark Strong

as The First and Foremost Phanfasm in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +3