Suggestions by @thepinkmenace

Gael García Bernal

as Zorro in Pulp Heroes!

Score: +3

Austin Butler

as Superman in Superman: Champion

Score: +2

Joanna Johnston

as Costume Designer in Clark: A Superman Story

Score: +2

Bill Skarsgård

as Richard, Duke of Gloucester in Robert Eggers's Richard III

Score: +9

Brittney Mack

as The Fates in Hadestown

Score: +1

Katrina Lenk

as The Fates in Hadestown

Score: +1

Gelsey Bell

as The Fates in Hadestown

Score: +1

Taraji P. Henson

as Persephone in Hadestown

Score: +2

Tom Waits

as Hades in Hadestown

Score: +4

Wayne Brady

as Hermes in Hadestown

Score: +1

Jasmine Cephas Jones

as Eurydice in Hadestown

Score: +2

Colton Ryan

as Orpheus in Hadestown

Score: +1

Francine Jamison-Tanchuck

as Costume Designer in Hadestown

Score: +1

Hannah Beachler

as Production Designer in Hadestown

Score: +1

Myron Kerstein

as Editor in Hadestown

Score: +1

Alice Brooks

as Cinematographer in Hadestown

Score: +1

Christopher Scott

as Choreographer in Hadestown

Score: +1

T Bone Burnett

as Composer in Hadestown

Score: +1

Anaïs Mitchell

as Producer in Hadestown

Score: +1

Anaïs Mitchell

as Writer in Hadestown

Score: +1