Suggestions by @teeyutes

Jack Elam

as Arthur "Boo" Radley in To Kill A Mockingbird (1952)

Score: +1

James Whitmore

as Ernie in It’s a Wonderful Life (1956)

Score: +1

Vincent Price

as 1960s in What Actors Could've Played The Green Goblin in Various Decades?

Score: +1

Lionel Barrymore

as 1920s in What Actors Could've Played The Green Goblin in Various Decades?

Score: +1

Burgess Meredith

as 1950s in What Actors Could've Played The Green Goblin in Various Decades?

Score: +2

Bruce Dern

as Gillespie in In the Heat of the Night (1977)

Score: +1

Walter Brennan

as Eric Endicott in In the Heat of the Night (1937)

Score: +1

Terry-Thomas

as Andre Trochard in We’re No Angels (1965)

Score: +1

James Robertson Justice

as Batiatus in Spartacus (1960)

Score: +1

Joan Hackett

as Mrs. Colbert in In the Heat of the Night (1977)

Score: +1

Donald Moffat

as Morris Gutman in Welcome to Mooseport (1994)

Score: +1

Ed Asner

as Stu in Welcome to Mooseport (1994)

Score: +1

David Tomlinson

as Andre Trochard in We’re No Angels (1975)

Score: +1

Albert Finney

as Jules in We’re No Angels (1975)

Score: +1

Cliff Robertson

as Joseph in We’re No Angels (1975)

Score: +1

Jessica Lange

as Sister Sharon Falconer in Elmer Gantry (1980)

Score: +1

Warren Beatty

as Elmer Gantry in Elmer Gantry (1980)

Score: +1

Faye Dunaway

as Lulu Bains in Elmer Gantry (1970)

Score: +1

Natalie Wood

as Sister Sharon Falconer in Elmer Gantry (1970)

Score: +1

James Coburn

as Elmer Gantry in Elmer Gantry (1970)

Score: +1