Suggestions by @squidward6

Nermal

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Garfield

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: -2

Figaro

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Si and Am

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Sox

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Cheshire Cat

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Sassy (Homeward Bound)

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Mittens

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Snowball (The Simpsons)

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Kitty Softpaws

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Puss in Boots (Shrek)

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Chloe (The Secret Life of Pets)

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +2

Oliver (Oliver & Company)

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Goose (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Thomas O'Malley

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Thackery Binx

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Toulouse

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Marie

as House cat in Fictional animals by species

Score: +1

Po Ping

as I Just Want to Be Badass in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Karen Wheeler

as Housewife in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1