Suggestions by @shadicmcgs

Christopher Lloyd

as Pachacamac in Knuckles the Echidna (Paramount + Sonic Team)

Score: +6

Ben Affleck

as Bruce Wayne in Batman Beyond (Live-action movie)

Score: -1

Lily Collins

as Blaze the Cat in Sonic Heroes: Sonic the Hedgehog 4

Score: +1

Jeff Gallup

as Jeb Jab in Scott the Woz

Score: +1

Ludi Lin

as Zack Taylor in Power Rangers (CW Style)

Score: +1

Josh Swickard

as Rex Mohs in Scott the Woz

Score: +2

Taron Egerton

as Lieutenant Zaram in Kamen Rider Wisp: Civil War

Score: +1

Joey Richter

as Jerry Atricks in Scott the Woz

Score: +3

Cameron Rostami

as Steel Wool in Scott the Woz

Score: 0

Ana Golja

as Liza Lotts in Scott the Woz

Score: +2

Tom Fujita

as Haruka Mizusawa in Kamen Rider Wisp: Civil War

Score: +1

Jeff Gallup

as The Employee in Scott the Woz

Score: 0

Austin North

as Jeb Jab in Scott the Woz

Score: 0

Timothée Chalamet

as Terry Lesler in Scott the Woz

Score: +3

Tom Holland

as Scott Wozniak in Scott the Woz

Score: +3

Julianne Collins

as Frankie Cahill in The Book

Score: +1

Taylor Richardson

as The Girl in Girl With No Name

Score: -8

Audrey Grace Marshall

as Paula in Earthbound

Score: +1

Richard Epcar

as Dr. Eggman in Sonic the Hedgehog Full Voice Cast

Score: +4

Willem Dafoe

as Dr Eggman in Sonic the Hedgehog

Score: +5