Suggestions by @moviedoc

William Fichtner

as Dr. Kirk Langstrom in Batman: Gotham Nights

Score: +1

Winston Duke

as Lucas Bishop in MCU Phase 6 X-Men

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Harvey Bullock in Batman: The Brave and the Bold

Score: +2

Brad Pitt

as Cable in MCU X-Men (2024)

Score: -1

Jason Momoa

as Sabertooth in MCU X-Men (2024)

Score: +1

Milo Ventimiglia

as Michael Corleone in Recasting The Godfather

Score: +1

Vincent Pastore

as Luca Brasi in Recasting The Godfather

Score: +1

Chazz Palminteri

as Vito Corleone in Recasting The Godfather

Score: 0

Tom Hardy

as Tom Hagen in Recasting The Godfather

Score: +1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Sonny Corleone in Recasting The Godfather

Score: +1

Steve Schirripa

as Clemenza in Recasting The Godfather

Score: 0

John Turturro

as Sollozzo in Recasting The Godfather

Score: +1

Liam Neeson

as Captain McCluskey in Recasting The Godfather

Score: +1

Giovanni Ribisi

as Fredo Corleone in Recasting The Godfather

Score: +2

Paul Newman

as Cyclops in X-Men (1960's)

Score: +3

David Harbour

as Det. Harvey Bullock in Batman (HBO TV Series) (2010s)

Score: +2

Pedro Pascal

as The Skull in Scarface (2023)

Score: +1

Michael Mando

as Omar Suarez in Scarface (2023)

Score: +1

Benicio del Toro

as Alejandro Sosa in Scarface (2023)

Score: +1

Andy Garcia

as Frank Lopez in Scarface (2023)

Score: +2