Suggestions by @easyquizylemonss

Lilah Fitzgerald

as Amelie in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

James Remar

as Alpha in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Sonja Sohn

as Beta in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Christian Slater

as Romeo in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Lisa Harrow

as Old Piper in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Susan Seaforth Hayes

as Old Piper in Charmed: The Return

Score: -1

Vanessa Kirby

as Patience in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Alexandra Breckenridge

as Misty in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Jenna Ortega

as Athena in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Nathalie Emmanuel

as Neena in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Jada Pinkett Smith

as Lemma La Croix in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Amy Adams

as Black Twin/Mel McArthur in Charmed: The Return

Score: +1

Kitana Turnbull

as Kinna Sanders in Legacies

Score: +2

Elizabeth McLaughlin

as Angelina Le Fay in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

China Anne McClain

as Lorraine McHartley in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

Michelle Rodriguez

as Neena in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

Sophie Simnett

as Patience in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

Hannah Emily Anderson

as Selene Bernavont in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: +1

Michelle Fairley

as Athena Beauchamp in Charmed: Darkness Rising

Score: 0

Thomas Doherty

as Captain Hook in Once Upon a Time

Score: 0